FRED stray light analysis ray tracing simulation through a multi-element lens system

Introduction

Stray Light Analysis

Stray light is the presence of unintended, and generally unwanted, light paths in an optical system that become a source of noise in the measured optical signal. These paths can be generated by events such as scattering from optical or mechanical surfaces and ghost paths caused by reflections from nominally transmissive surfaces.

FRED's stray light analysis toolset has been developed over many years to make these paths easier to find and understand, making FRED an indispensable platform for stray light analysis.

This article highlights several FRED capabilities for simulating and identifying stray light in your system, including:

  • Detailed ray trace controls
  • How to generate ray paths
  • The Raytrace Paths Report
  • Filtering with Ray Filters and the 'Analysis Lasso' filter
  • The Stray Light Report

Read our 3-part series here

The NASA Terrestrial Planet Finder (TPF)

A space-based telescope concept for detecting planets around stars. It is a multi-telescope interferometric system in which the star image is nulled out, revealing the planet.

As particulate contamination levels increase over time, instrument sensitivity degrades over the operational lifetime of the system.

NASA Terrestrial Planet Finder concept illustration showing multiple space telescopes in formation
FRED simulation model of the TPF interferometric system showing two telescopesTPF interferometer optical path diagram showing fold mirrors, phase plate, and focal plane

Demonstration of Principle

Left: Simulation model of the system. Light enters from two telescopes, and one path includes a phase plate.

(A): With direct imaging, only the star image is visible.

(B): When the phase plate is adjusted to null the star image, the planet becomes clearly visible.

TPF direct imaging result showing star image at focal plane (A)
(A)
TPF nulled star result showing planet revealed at focal plane (B)
(B)

Performance Degradation Due to Scatter

In the actual hardware, at least two scatter mechanisms are present on the primary and secondary mirrors:

Surface roughness:

  • 20A rms. Total integrated scatter (TIS) = 0.0006%.

Particulate contamination:

  • Mirror surfaces are covered according to the MIL-STD-1246 distribution.
  • Two levels were evaluated: CL400 (0.1%) and CL600 (1.0%).
BSDF scatter plot for 20A rms surface roughness on a TPF mirror showing TIS around 0.0006%
Surface Roughness BSDF
BSDF scatter plot for particulate contamination on a TPF mirror showing the MIL-STD-1246 distribution
Particle Scatter BSDF

Simulation Results

Observe a planet orbiting a bright star

Hubble Space Telescope image of the Fomalhaut star system showing a planet orbiting a bright star

No surface roughness, no contamination

FRED simulation result with no surface roughness and no contamination showing a clear star and planet
Star and orbiting planet

20A rms roughness, 0.1% contamination

FRED simulation result with 20A rms roughness and 0.1% contamination showing reduced contrast
Reduced contrast

20A rms roughness, 1.0% contamination

FRED simulation result with 20A rms roughness and 1.0% contamination showing a destroyed image
Image is destroyed

Stray Light Analysis of the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST)

The Large Synoptic Survey Telescope (LSST) at the Rubin Observatory is a large ground-based telescope that can survey the entire sky every three nights to build a detailed map of the universe while searching for faint and moving objects (www.lsst.org).

FRED was used to study the initial proposed design and identify stray light mechanisms that required unique baffling approaches.

FRED stray light simulation model of the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope optical system
Artist rendering of the LSST telescope inside its enclosure at the Rubin Observatory
Artist rendering of LSST
FRED optical model of the LSST telescope showing the full enclosure structure
FRED model of LSST
Optical layout diagram of the LSST showing primary, secondary, tertiary mirrors, and camera
Optical layout of LSST
Cutaway view of the FRED model of LSST showing internal baffles and optical components
Cutaway view of FRED model

The FRED Optical Model

To be effective, computer modeling of telescope systems must be accurate and sufficiently detailed.

In the FRED model, the mirrors use a silver coating with 94% average reflectivity and Harvey-Shack scatter models for surface roughness.

Harvey-Shack scatter model parameter table for LSST mirrors and lenses showing micro-roughness, transmitted scatter, and reflected scatter values
  • A Mie particle model was also used for contamination with the EST-STD-1246D distribution model.
  • The optical filters use an anti-reflective coating with average reflectivity below 1.5%. The specular reflectivity of the CCD detector is set to 18%.
  • Non-optical surfaces were assigned a Black Paint scatter model for Aeroglaze Z306.

Stray Light Analysis Results

"PST" Point Source Transmittance

A PST calculation analyzes stray light in a system. It is defined as the total power at the detector divided by the total light entering the system.

PST was calculated for telescope orientations from 0 to 80 degrees (b) and for five different azimuth angles. The results in (c) showed three distinct causes of stray light.

  • (i) 2 - 10 deg: Surface roughness from the primary and secondary mirrors
  • (ii) 10 - 40 deg: Scatter from the baffles and other non-optical surfaces
  • (iii) 40 - 80 deg: Scatter from the dome above the telescope
PST formula: PST equals P_det(theta, phi) divided by P_inc(theta, phi)
(a)
FRED model of the LSST telescope tilted to show the telescope orientation used for PST calculation
(b)
LSST PST calculation chart showing Log10(PST) versus source input angle for five azimuth angles with three distinct stray light regimes
(c)

About Photon Engineering

Founded in 1997, Photon Engineering is an optical engineering software and consulting firm and the creator of the industry-leading ray tracing software FRED.

CBS is the exclusive Canadian distributor for Photon Engineering's FRED Optical Engineering software.

Photon Engineering logo